The Voice and the Rising : The Cold ordinary dailiness of it.

The Voice and the Rising : The Cold ordinary dailiness of it.

Always remember, unless one commits, nothing changes for oneself.

 The mind may tell you, "If you don't make a commitment, then you haven't made a commitment" — but if you follow that and don't commit, you are committed to not making commitments. So not committing is still a choice. It just keeps everything the same.

Here's why. Without commitment, every discomfort tells you to stop or run. With commitment, that same discomfort just becomes information. "This hurts" stops being a command to quit — it's just a fact on a Way you already chose to walk.

The mind also loves to say, "I'll commit when I feel comfortable, or less scared or more ready." But that's backwards. Action doesn't follow feeling. It is the other way. Feeling follows action. Commitment doesn't wait for confidence — confidence shows up after you commit.

You cannot opt out of it. Not committing to early zazen means committing to your past oversleeping habits. Not committing to a relationship means committing to being alone. Not committing to a Way means committing to its absence. You are always committed to something. The only question is whether you picked it by your choice on purpose.

This is not abstract.

Every morning, a few minutes before the alarm, I wake in my room at the Zendo — a couple of metres from the forest, Perumalmalai. I can see the silhouette of that towering mountain through the window and a bit of sky. Also the rustle of the wind and singing of the waterfall. The temperature is in single digits during that time, most of the days throughout the year. And the same voice speaks within me, above the cacophonous symphony of the Tinnitus orchestra, without fail: Should I skip zazen this morning? I'm not feeling well. Shall I just message and go back to the comfort of the blanket. I know that voice. I have even named that part of my mind. I take a breath. A deep one. And then I chant Shiku se gan mon and then Enn mei jikku Kannon Gyo. And I rise. Every single morning. The chants do not suppress the voice with the name — they simply remind me of what I have already chosen. That gap between the voice and the rising is where commitment actually lives. Not in the dramatic moment of deciding, but in the cold dailiness of it.

So don't wait for that voice to vanish — for the fear and apprehensions to disappear. Those fears and apprehensions are not a sign you are wrong. They are a sign you are finally making a real choice. Real choices mean losing other paths. That loss hurts. But that hurt is small, and it is temporary.

The pain of non-commitment — the slow fading of what could have been, the quiet regret of the road not taken — that pain stays.

Scottish mountaineer W.H. Murray knew this. Scouting the Himalayas in 1950, he wrote: "Until one is committed, there is hesitancy... the moment one definitely commits oneself, then providence moves too." He paired it with a line he loosely rendered from Goethe: "Whatever you can do, or dream you can, begin it. Boldness has genius, power, and magic in it." Murray's scouting of the southern approach through the Khumbu Icefall proved the route to Everest was viable — the blueprint that made the 1953 summit possible. He could not make that final climb himself, felled by altitude sickness. But his commitment had already done its work.

I had Murray's words on my desk for quite some time. I read them every single day — and then procrastinated. That piece of paper is lost now, swallowed somewhere in the tides of time. But I think traces of it remain, somewhere in the mind. Not in the part that voices otherwise.

Perhaps what quietly internalised all of this was Acceptance and Commitment Therapy. Every step of it runs through my mind whenever I face a real choice. It begins with acceptance — meeting a thought, emotion, or feeling that is not comfortable, not convenient, and choosing to face it rather than flee. Being present helps enormously with that. Then comes defusion — recognising that the limiting voice in the mind is just that: a voice, a thought, not a literal truth. This aligns, in its own way, with Buddhist teaching. There is no single fixed self inside the mind. We are all, to some extent, a chorus of voices — the difference between those who suffer from that and the rest of us is only one of scale. What orients us is knowing what truly matters — that clarity sets the direction. And from that clarity, committed action becomes possible.

So committed action always begins in clear awareness. And it ends there too.

That daily, unglamorous, cold-morning repetition is the practice and the living itself — not preparation for anything else.

And after all this drama of mine — reflection, writing to the bone, blog, posting — when I reach the Zendo hall, Fr. AMA walks in for the early morning zazen without fail. We just celebrated his 90th birthday on 21 May. And for a moment I think: how manyth zazen sitting will this be for him — and what really motivates him.

On Marshmallows, Attention, and the Long Walk to Mannarkkad in the Rain…

On Marshmallows, Attention, and the Long Walk to Mannarkkad in the Rain…

Good moment, dear reader.

I want to begin slowly today. No grand thesis to prove. No ten-point framework to deliver. Just… a few thoughts that have been sitting with me since last evening — the way certain things stay with you through the night, and are still there in the morning, quiet and patient, waiting to be looked at.

I run a year-long inner work program called Kokoro-Zen-Do in Action. We are six months in. A small, earnest cohort of people who signed up — bravely, I think — to spend a year doing the kind of slow, uncomfortable, unglamorous work that does not fit into a reel or a listicle.

Yesterday morning, I put a reminder in our Sangha community group.

Our planned Sangha Dialogue — 27 May, 8:30 PM. A gentle nudge into the shared stream of our days. I typed it out, pressed send, and went about my morning. Thinking nothing more of it.

Now — I want you to know I am smiling as I write this. More the kind of smile that arises when life arranges itself into an accidental koan. A reminder about presence… that no one noticed.

A message about gathering… that dissolved somewhere into the scroll. Between a forwarded recipe and a motivational quote, most likely.

I thought: well. There is something here worth saying out loud.

So here I am, saying it. Not to my cohort only. But to anyone who might find themselves in it.

Dogen said: To study Zen is to study the self.

I have been living with that sentence for years. It does not get smaller with familiarity. If anything, the longer I sit with it, the more I find it has rooms I had not yet entered.

Because here is what I think Dogen was pointing at — and what I believe is true not only of Zen, but of any genuine inner work:

It is not about what we accumulate.

Not the knowledge. Not the frameworks. Not the vocabulary. Not the certificates on the wall or the books on the shelf or the meditation apps on the phone with the streak counter that quietly judges you every morning.

It is about integration. Shadow integration. The slow, uncomfortable, often unglamorous work of meeting the parts of ourselves we have been managing, performing around, quietly afraid of — and bringing them home. Bit by bit. Season by season.

That work… does not happen quickly.

It cannot be rushed. It cannot be hacked. It cannot be summarised in a bullet point or captured in a ninety-second reel.

And I think — I gently suspect — that this is where many of us are finding it hard.

Let me tell you about a marshmallow.

Back in 1972, a psychologist at Stanford named Walter Mischel ran a simple experiment. He brought children — four years old, five years old — into a small room. On the table in front of them, he placed one marshmallow. Then he made them an offer.

You can eat this now. That is perfectly fine. Or — you can wait. I am going to step out. If the marshmallow is still here when I come back, I will bring you two.

Then he left.

Some children ate the marshmallow almost immediately. Some waited — and the waiting was exquisite to observe. They covered their eyes. They turned away. They sang to themselves. They petted the marshmallow as if it were a small animal. They did everything in their power to hold the discomfort of — not yet.

What I find most moving about this experiment is not the outcome data. It is the image itself.

A small child. A single marshmallow. And the enormous, silent battle between now and later.

Because that battle — dressed in different clothes, playing out on a different stage — is exactly what many of us are navigating in our inner lives right now.

Any genuine inner work asks you to invest in something you cannot yet see. To practice something whose fruits are not immediately measurable. To sit with the discomfort of I am not sure this is working, I am not sure I am doing it right, I am not sure anything is happening at all — and to keep showing up anyway.

That is the marshmallow.

And the gratification… is genuinely far ahead.

Now. About attention.

I want to tell you something first. About who I was as a child. Because I think it matters.

I grew up reading big books. Not summaries. Not excerpts. The full, brick-like, glorious things. Gone with the Wind. The Count of Monte Cristo. Arabian Nights. And Ithihyamala — that magnificent Malayalam collection of temple legends and folk stories that my grandmother kept on the highest shelf, which made it, naturally, the first thing I wanted to reach. I read these not as tasks but as worlds I moved into and lived in for weeks. You did not rush The Count of Monte Cristo. You let it take you. You surrendered to its pace.

And cricket. Five-day Test cricket.

We were living then in Thenkara. A small village — and I mean small in the way that really means something — no electricity, leave alone a television. The world beyond our village arrived slowly, if at all.

But there was Kanna mama. My father’s cousin. He lived in Mannarkkad, in a big ancestral house. And that house was always — always — open. Not just for us. For everyone. For the whole extended, sprawling, uninvited crowd of us who would assemble there for the big game  or simply because there was nowhere else to go and Kanna mama never, not once, made anyone feel like there was anywhere else they should be.

Five full days for a Test match. The host family never once complained. Never once hinted that the crowd was too much. The house was simply… open. Food appeared. Tea appeared. And we watched. Hour after hour. Day after day. The long, slow, meditative rhythm of Test cricket — the building of an innings, the shifting of pressure, the patience required of both batsman and bowler and, crucially, of the watcher.

That is a kind of attention that is very hard to describe to someone who has not felt it. A sustained, willing, wholehearted giving of your time and presence to something unfolding at its own pace, on its own terms, with no guarantee of a dramatic finish.

And then there was the night of 21 June 1986.

Brazil versus France. World Cup quarter-final. Guadalajara, Mexico.

My father decided we would go to Kanna mama’s house to watch. My brother and I didn’t need convincing. And so we walked — from Thenkara to Mannarkkad — in the rain. I don’t remember exactly how far. I remember the rain. I remember my father walking ahead, steady, not complaining. I remember the particular quality of that anticipation — the feeling of moving toward something through discomfort, because the thing was worth it.

We arrived. The house was full and warm and loud. Kanna mama’s house always was.

Brazil lost, as it happens. On penalties. One of the most beautiful and heartbreaking matches in the history of the sport. Zico missed the crucial kick. I can still see it.

After forty years, I can still recall both team lineups. Every name. Every position.

That is what deep attention does to an experience. It burns it in. It makes it yours forever.

Kanna mama passed away three weeks ago.

And here is one of life’s quietly astonishing circles: he left his sprawling ancestral house almost right in the middle  of  Mannarkkad — that very house, the one we walked toward in the rain that June night — to Thenkara. The village we had walked from. The place where we lived in 1986 with no electricity, leave alone a television.

His house came to Thenkara where I started that long walk to watch … a football game ! . All those years later.

I don’t have a neat way to say what that means. I am not sure it needs one. Some circles don’t need explaining. They just need witnessing.

Now I look back at all of this — the big books, the five-day Tests, the walk to Mannarkkad in the rain — and I see something I could not have named then.

We were, without knowing it, practicing the marshmallow.

Every single day.

We were practicing the art of staying. Of not reaching for the easier thing. Of letting something unfold at its own pace and trusting that the unfolding was worth your presence.

And now… I catch myself reaching for my phone four minutes into reading a book I have been meaning to sit with for weeks. Not because anything has arrived. Not because anyone needs me. Simply because the silence of reading has become, in four minutes, slightly uncomfortable. Slightly too slow.

The phone is the marshmallow. And I eat it.

I tell you this not as confession for its own sake. I tell you because I am swimming in the same water as everyone else. The current pulls at me too. Every single day.

We live in an age that has been ingeniously engineered to shorten our attention. Instagram reels. T20 cricket — where an entire story of contest and drama and reversal, that once unfolded over five long contemplative days, is now compressed into three electric hours. Fast food. Micro-learning. The podcast that delivers the key ideas from a book in eleven minutes. The listicle summarising a work that took a human being seven years and great personal suffering to write — delivered brisk and tidy, before your coffee goes cold.

I use these things too. I am not standing apart from any of this.

But I want to name what it does to us. Cumulatively. Quietly. Over time.

It trains us away from dwelling.

It trains us to expect resolution quickly. Insight quickly. Transformation quickly. And when transformation does not arrive on that timeline — when the practice feels dry, when the book doesn’t open, when the sitting produces nothing but a restless leg and a wandering mind — we conclude, almost automatically: something must be wrong.

Nothing is wrong.

You are simply being asked to walk to Mannarkkad in the rain.

To show up for the five-day Test.

To let The Count of Monte Cristo take as long as it takes.

To let something work on you the way a long, slow monsoon works on a hillside — not dramatically, not in a single downpour, but reshaping everything, steadily, over time. The hillside does not announce its transformation. It simply receives the rain.

And one morning — you cannot say exactly when — everything looks different.

I want to say something now that I hope lands gently.

The practice is the returning. The quiet, undramatic act of coming back — half-asleep sometimes, carrying more than you expected sometimes, having eaten the marshmallow sometimes — and being here anyway.

Shunryu Suzuki Roshi said something I have returned to more times than I can count: Each of you is perfect the way you are… and you can use a little improvement. Both things simultaneously true. You are exactly where you need to be. And you are still unfolding. This is not a contradiction. This is the Enso itself — complete, and yet still being drawn.

Let me be honest about one more thing before I close.

When I began my own journey — the longer one, the one that eventually led me to this work — I was deeply uncomfortable with not knowing how it would turn out. I wanted the map. I wanted the guarantee. I wanted someone further along to look at me and say: Yes. If you do this, you will arrive there. And there is worth going.

Nobody said that. Nobody could.

Because the whole point — the irreducible, inalienable, sometimes infuriating point — is that you have to walk into the not-knowing. Through the rain. In the dark. Not knowing if Brazil will win.

What I can offer — not as a promise, but as the quiet testimony of someone who has been walking longer and has fallen more times than he would like to admit — is this:

The walking changes you.

Not in the way you expected. Not on the timeline you planned. But it changes you in the way that lasts — quietly, irrevocably, from somewhere so deep inside that you often don’t notice it happening at all. You only notice it later, looking back, when you realise you responded to something the way you never used to respond. When you find a small spaciousness where there used to be only a wall.

That is the fruit. And it takes its own time to ripen.

It cannot be reminded into existence.

Not even by a WhatsApp message on a Tuesday morning.

So.

Be tender with yourselves.

Be patient with what is quietly ripening in the dark.

Trust the slow monsoon.

Walk to Mannarkkad, even in the rain.

And if, on some days, all you can do is remember that you are on a path — that is enough. That remembering, however fleeting, however sandwiched between a recipe forward and a motivational quote — that is the path. You are on it. Even now.

One question to sit with — no need to answer it anywhere but inside yourself:

Where in my life right now is something asking me to wait… and what would it mean, just for today, to say yes to that waiting?

Sit with it.

No hurry.

In Gassho — Metta and Mudita,

Vishy Sankara

kokorozendo.life

P.S. If something in these pages stirred something in you — Cohort 2 opens September 2026. No hurry. No pressure. Just — you will know if it is for you.

Speck of Sand, View from Above: The Overview Effect Doesn’t Need a Rocket Ship

Speck of Sand, View from Above: The Overview Effect Doesn’t Need a Rocket Ship

Victor Glover, who was an astronaut in the recent Moon expedition said in April 2026 "the gratitude of seeing what we saw, doing what we did and being with who I was with... it's too big to just be in one body".. But then this overview effect is not just one event.. There are many astronauts reported this .. And many of them turned deeply spiritual. Like Edgar Mitchell who started his institute on Noetic science.

The Overview Effect isn't just visual or another experience. It is ontological. Meaning... there comes a sudden, overwhelming knowing that everything is connected and the universe is conscious and intentional. One can't reason one's way to it through any belief system or concepts. It is not something that you go to — it arrives.

But then one does not have to be an astronaut to have one...In the University of Exeter's Stoic Week , they teach you that Stoic meditation. "The View from Above" (Cosmic perspective). Don’t remember was it taught by Pythagoras.. It leaves one with a deep sense of unity and interconnectedness. A reduction of ego and personal anxiety.. and our day to day life problems becomes smaller and manageable/livable.

I think i have that recording... If anyone want to try out ,DM me...

But then It does not have to be view from above and outside.. when we look from inside too one can get that effect.. While sitting in Zazen and Shikatanza , often i experience the same..

Maybe that is why Fr. AMA always discourages me from sharing my experiences from Zazen. He terms it as Makyo — delusions. And also reminds me — it does not happen by our effort. So one shouldn't be egoistic about it. It is a grace.

But then this is not just views from a mountain.. way back in 2012 from Thuwal, KSA i wrote this..

"It has been some 6 years. Musings seems to have lost that melancholic tint. Most probably time still is the best antibiotic on memories. Even my mother's voice was less of tears this time and mostly tinged in matter of fact recollection. And partly orchestrated and rest coincidental, I found myself in the middle of a desert on a rather uneventful death anniversary day of my dad. Absolutely in the middle of nowhere. Almost like the proverbial empty quartet. Miles and miles of very plain land lay in all 8 directions from that oil gathering station. The barren brownish land needed a mercury level to make it self realize that it is not that flat. No tree, leave alone a blade of grass or hill was in sight.

Though the picture was in stark contrast with the lush green picturesque place in hinterland Kerala, where I was born and brought up, there indeed was something exhilarating about this place. Irritatingly the place did look familiar to me. Then I realized the number of hours I had spent as a kid reading the stories of "The thousand and one nights" (Arabian nights) casting a spell now. After all Aladdin got his magic lamp from the souks of Muscat. The deadening silence and sense of space can alter anyone's state of mind and make him a time traveller.

No wonder, Thesiger the last of the great explorers wrote in his classic travelogue "No one can live this life and emerge unchanged". In another perspective it is a paradox. While an oxford educated blue blooded Brit named Thesiger, loathed the modern civilization of cars and other amenities and adored lives of Bedus and nomads of Arabia, most of the current day – sons of soil – 's only aim is "coming to town". It is the town built on reclaimed sea from the riches of oil and banking where camels are replaced by Prados.

As the horizon was bathed in the color of saffron, i became aware of the sun setting not very far off. Maybe it is going into another oil well. The Sun gets more beautiful hues in the desert than in the sea. It is in those rather hazy moments with no specific starting or end points where day meets night, you realize that human lives does mirror nature.

When one visualize oneself rather egotistically as the centre of this vast ocean of sand, it is rather easy to forget as a person we are nothing more than a spec of sand in dunes of time."

The “overview effect” is not tied to altitude but to attitude. Whether through cosmic vision, desert silence, or the ordinariness of Zazen, it’s the same shift: the ego dissolves, and one sees oneself as a speck of sand in the dunes of time.

The Overview Effect can be even from the inside out, not from above. The desert, like space, offers negative capability: a scale so vast that the usual stories stop running.

One doesn’t need to leave the planet. One just need enough silence, enough flatness, enough saffron light, for the "I" to soften at its edges.  That's the real gift, isn't it? That the effect is available to anyone willing to sit still enough—whether on a cushion, in a desert, or just closing their eyes and letting the view from above settle in. No spacesuit required.

Standing in line and Sitting in silence.

Standing in line and Sitting in silence.

Kerala ex-CM Pinarayi Vijayan waiting for a train at Kannur station… it reminds me of those earlier gestures of ordinariness my father Sankara spoke of—Achutha Menon quietly boarding a KSRTC bus back to Thrissur, EMS living in a small party flat in Thiruvananthapuram till the very end. Power there is not a throne to cling to, but something handed back without fuss.

Kerala, God's own country and devil's too, carries this paradox in its people. Educated, alert, unwilling to tolerate arrogance—even when the government has achievements to show, they vote it out. And those who lose power do not resist returning to ordinary life. They stand at bus stops, railway platforms, in small apartments, blending back into the crowd.

Once, Sandeep Dixit came to APU as a guest lecturer on Policy and Politics. I asked him about his mother Sheila Dikshit—who governed Delhi for fifteen years, who held a capital city of millions in her hands, who oversaw its transformation through the Commonwealth Games years. He answered without performance, without pride or self-pity. She lives in a small apartment, he said. No lift. Knee pain keeps her from going down the stairs, from attending any public function.

That detail landed quietly but hard.

Power is partly logistics—cars, offices, access, priority, crowds parting. The moment it ends, you discover how much of your physical world was organised around that apparatus. The knees that once carried her through rallies and corridors now needed a lift that wasn't there. The radius of a former Chief Minister reduced to the walls of a walkup flat.

And yet—no bitterness in how Sandeep said it. Just a fact. This is where she lives. This is her world now.

It rhymes with the Pinarayi photograph in a way that surprises you. Both images strip away the Monroe mask and leave just a person. One sitting on a platform bench, waiting for a train that will not wait for him. One sitting inside, unable to go down the stairs.

But you don't have to lose power to practice this ordinariness. Some carry it while still at the peak.

At Wipro, I saw Azim Premji walk into the cafeteria many times — then Chairman of one of India's great corporations — and simply join the queue. No aide holding a tray, no table reserved, no subtle parting of the crowd. He would stand and wait his turn like everyone else, and he always chose the Healthy Menu. Now, I was never entirely sure whether that was a genuine commitment to nutrition or simply the wisdom of a shorter queue — and I say this having tasted it once, it was not particularly appetizing. But there he was. The chairman. Waiting. Choosing the simpler thing.

There is something in that image that belongs alongside the railway platform and the walkup apartment. Not loss, not limitation — but choice. A daily, quiet, almost stubborn insistence on not letting the Monroe mask harden into the only face you have.

And then there is Fr. AMA — our Zen Master at Kanzeon Zendo. His ninetieth birthday was not a different day. As usual, he was there for early morning zazen, sitting in silence as he has through decades of dawns, as if the years themselves were just passing weather. After the sitting, we all joined together to cut a cake and wish him. Before that I asked him — how does it feel to be ninety?

He smiled. And said: "Tired and peaceful."

Not grateful. Not blessed. Not the performance of a milestone. Just two words carrying the honest weight of ninety years, with nowhere left to hide and no desire to hide anywhere. A man who never put the Monroe mask on in the first place — and so had nothing to remove, nothing to hand back, nothing to prove by standing in a queue or sitting on a platform bench.

The cake came after the silence. That detail is everything.

There is a teaching here: roles dissolve, presence remains. The train platform, the bus seat, the cafeteria queue, the apartment without a lift, the zazen cushion on a ninetieth birthday morning — these are not falls from grace, but reminders that masks cannot last forever. Kerala's greatest gift may not be its backwaters or greenery, but this democratic ordinariness — where even ex-Chief Ministers wait with the people, unadorned, unafraid. And perhaps Delhi's most honest image is not its monuments or its power corridors, but a former CM quietly watching the city she built from a window she can no longer easily leave. And perhaps corporate India's most quietly radical image is a billionaire chairman holding a cafeteria tray, wondering, like the rest of us, whether the healthy option is really worth it.

And perhaps the most radical image of all is a Zen master on his ninetieth birthday, sitting in the same silence he sat in on every other day — because for him, there was never a mask to slip.

It is both God's country and devil's country because it refuses to sanctify power. What it sanctifies instead is the ordinary pulse of life.

The train platform, the apartment without a lift, the cafeteria queue, the zazen cushion — all say the same thing.

You were never the chair. You were always just yourself.

Where Else…

Where Else…

The van, the auto, the waste cart, the seaside library, the guest room, the kitchen – all are libraries. All are literature.

On the way to Kochi, someone had named his tourist carrier Rumi Ride. A Force Urbania. Dark grey. Kollam registration. And right in the middle of Cherai beach — not a bookshop, not a university — a two-storeyed library. Named Janakeya Vayanasala. A People’s Reading Room, in Malayalam. As if the beach needed one. As if, of course it does.

Francis Bacon, Father of Science, wrote in his essay Of Studies — Reading maketh a full man, Writing an exact man. Most people stop there. But the full sentence adds: conference a ready man. Conversation. Dialogue. The third leg. The one we always drop, as if reading and writing alone were enough. Bacon knew better. Readiness is not solitary. It happens in the presence of another mind.

In Kerala, that third leg has always been the street. Not the seminar hall. The street corner where an auto driver names his vehicle after a novel.

A few years ago, a photo went around of an auto in Kerala. The driver, Pradeep, had named his three-wheeler The Alchemist — after reading the Malayalam translation of Paulo Coelho’s novel. That was ten years before the photo was taken. He had changed the vehicle a couple of times. He never changed the name. Someone photographed it, tagged Coelho on Twitter, and the Brazilian writer — fifteen million followers — reposted it with just this: Kerala, India (thank you very much for the photo). Pradeep became an internet sensation without quite intending to. Coelho probably smiled and moved on. But the auto kept running. Same name. Same roads.

And then there is Dhanuja Kumari. She is a sanitation worker in Thiruvananthapuram, with the Haritha Karma Sena — the door-to-door waste collection service. She dropped out of school in the ninth grade. She began writing on scrap paper. Not to publish. Just to cope. What came out was a memoir — Chengalchoolayile Ente Jeevitham. My Life in Chengalchoola. Published in 2014. By 2024, it was part of the BA curriculum at Kannur University and the MA curriculum at Calicut University. She still collects waste in the mornings. She is writing her second book. Her colony has a library. She started it. It is called Wings of Women.

Two libraries. One on a beach, one in a colony. Both named after people.

Pradeep changed the vehicle. Never the name. Dhanuja wrote on scrap paper. It ended up in syllabi.

I remember reading, a long time ago, how Mahasweta Devi — the Bengali literary giant — encouraged an ordinary rickshaw puller (Manoranjan Byapari) to write. It stayed with me. I didn’t know then why. I think I do now.

After my own days of trauma — the nights, the twilights, the dawns — I sat in an online writing workshop and learned one thing. Perspectives matter. But more than that: those who have suffered, who have tasted the salt in their own tears — they are the ones who write literature. Mostly.

Rumi on a tourist van. Coelho on an autorickshaw. A library facing the sea.

Where else.

On our last day at Kochi, I told Nishad, who was taking care of us at Kochi, that we got to pay a visit to Kaladi Sankara’s birthplace. I had been there a couple of times. Thara has not. In the dedication page of my first published book “Fallen Flower and Fragrant Grass”, I had penned, “There were three Sankaras in my life.. EMS, Sankara and Adi Sankara. Of the three, it was Sankara, my late father, who taught me without teaching me to walk on the Middle Way between left and right. I dedicate this book to his wonderful memories.” And on our way, there was a board Pazhayidam Naivedyam. That triggered a photo of a Sadya on leaf shared by my sister Sandhya when she was visiting Guruvayoor, just a week back. My sister Sandhya, my nephew Anand, and my brother-in-law Manjunath — when they visited Guruvayoor last month — had their lunch at Pazhayidam Ruchi, a restaurant run by him.

Pazhayidam Mohanan Namboothiri.

And then, in the kitchen, another stage: Pazhayidam (literally “Old Place” in Malayalam, often contrasted with Puthiyaidam — “New Place”) is always fresh in taste. A six-flavoured culinary art that never tires the eater. Even those weary of life, ready to die, find themselves returning to the rasa — the essence of life — through it… He would say that life thirty years ago was not beautiful. After completing a degree in chemistry, there was a search for jobs. Nothing was working out. He started supplying equipment to school and college laboratories. That too failed midway. Then he began to lose hope. He was 28 years old. Sitting at home without any work or employment, he even thought of death. Even when he was completely depressed, he did not forget the path to the Kuttichathan Public Library. Behind that journey was his love for M.T.’s stories. When it felt like darkness was ahead, standing at a junction, he happened to flip through a weekly magazine hanging in a shop. In it was the beginning of M.T. Vasudevan Nair’s Randamoozham. It started like this: “That day, the sea had a dark colour…” He read the chapter titled Yatra two or three times. His mind told him that if he left the world without finishing this novel, it would be a loss. He journeyed with the novel until the 51st issue. Later, as brand ambassador for a food product, Mohanan Namboothiri earned his name and fame cooking for thousands at Kerala School Festival (one of the most reported events in Kerala), holding rare records and earning accolades.

Not sure Sandhya was aware of the story.

On our way to Kochi, Thara and I stayed at Usha Aunty and Dr. Radhakrishnan’s home in Coimbatore. Family friends for forty years. In the guest room, on the table there was a book. The Academy of Magic. Written by their granddaughter, Sanvi. A schoolgirl. Just that — a child’s first published story. No syllabus. No struggle. Only the ordinary miracle of a child who wrote. Who knows. I was about to take it and read it, then Nyra, the author’s cousin sister walked in to talk to Thara and I, and the rest of the evening went for it. So I added that book to my reading queue. The title of the book sounds like one of those J.K. Rowling series. “The Academy of Magic”. Who knows she may be the next J.K. Rowling.

The van, the auto, the waste cart, the seaside library, the guest room, the kitchen — all are libraries. All are literature.

Where else? Everywhere there is hunger. Not for food. For the thing that makes food worth making. Last month, my family sat at his table. They didn’t need to know. That’s how it works.

Being Irrelevant, and Other Things I Learned at University…

Being Irrelevant, and Other Things I Learned at University…

[Photo: Rupali, Flavia, and me — outside Pixel Park, APU Campus, Bangalore, during one of our APU days. Original photo reimagined as a time-travel — returning us to the child’s seat, a gentle leap backward into the schoolyard of learning and ordinariness. 🙂 ]]

There is a particular kind of madness in going back to university in your forties. Not an online course. Not a weekend workshop. A full-time, show-up-every-day, write-your-assignments, sit-in-a-classroom PG course— surrounded by students who were born around the time you were writing your first appraisal at work. In 2016, that is exactly what I did, walking away from a perfectly good career in IT to join Azim Premji University, Bangalore, for an MA in Education. I had watched that old comedy Back to School as a teenager and found it funny. I had no idea I was taking notes.

During those two years, I was the oldest student in the university. Many of the professors were younger than me — including my erstwhile colleague Vikas Maniar. I think I did attempt to follow his footsteps. After an MBA from IIMA, he had built a great career at Wipro, then moved on to work in the social sector, and eventually did a Ph.D. from TISS on Education. His was one of the courses I attended — in fact, I did two courses with him.

There were other real stalwart professors too: Dr. Rohit Dhankar (Philosophy of Education), Dr. Kaustav Roy (Marx to Laing to Phenomenology to Hermeneutics!), Dr. Rajasshree, Dr. Indira Vijayasimha, and Dr. Indrani Bhattacharji — who taught me, or tried to teach me, Epistemology. She had two Ph.Ds, the second one from the University of Massachusetts on Epistemology. And she had Gettier as one of her professors there. Gettier deserves a full blog of his own — the philosopher who dismantled Plato's theory of Justified True Belief in roughly 800 words, producing one of the most cited papers in the history of Philosophy.

But my best memories from those two years are a handful of moments.

One. Along with me, two of my friends from Sobha Hillview had joined the course. We used to carpool. Rupali and Flavia. And here is the thing — when we were classmates at APU, Flavia's son Ryan, Rupali's son Raghav, and my son Rishi were simultaneously classmates at The Valley School, KFI, Bangalore. Three parents studying the philosophy of education, while their sons shared a classroom at a Krishnamurti school. I am not sure life gets more poetic than that. All three of us did quite well too in the course— firmly on the right-hand side of the bell curve. 🙂

Two. I got elected to the Student Council during the first year — after surviving an open debate in front of all voters, where two of my opponents were genuinely brilliant orators. One had graduated from Visva-Bharati, the other from St. Stephen's. A long time ago, I had lost a college union election at Government Victoria College quite badly. That had sat as something incomplete on a checklist inside my heart. This felt like closing that loop. Though my bosses boss at Wipro was then Vice Chancelor of University, I could organize protest against  parking fee hike or food quality at canteen etc- a delicious iron not lost on me.  🙂

Three. Once, I received an O+ for one of my papers, and I was trying to use it to motivate my son Manu — showing off, really. He immediately replied: "Papa, when I was 12, my football coach made me play in the age group of 10, and we won a football match. So at this age, getting an O+ while studying with younger people is no big deal. It is like me going back to Primary Class 2."

He deflated my ego balloon with a sharp and incisive argument. After that, I never shared my grades with him. And luckily, universities do not have CTMs — Child-Teacher Meetings for reviewing parents-as-students.

A few years after I left APU, Manu did get an admission there. I wrote to my professor: "My son Manas is going to join your university — and BEWARE, he is a tougher nut with a sharper mind." Pat came the reply: "We took care of you. We will take care of your son too. Send him here."

But then he chose Jindal Global University. So they never had to.

And lastly — during the Covid years, I tried to get into a Ph.D. at ISEC, a prestigious institute in Bangalore. I managed to rank 2nd in their entrance exam. The interview was online. The Director scanned through my one-page research proposal — "A Phenomenological Analysis of Krishnamurti's Teaching in Education" — and asked, very derisively, "Can't you do something useful?"

I feigned as if I had not heard that comment.

Then he said, "Who is going to guide you in these things? If you choose another, more relevant proposal, come and meet us."

I never went back. Maybe I never had another relevant research proposal for him. Or maybe I was simply irrelevant.

That research proposal, by the way, was my thesis course for three full credits with Dr. Kaustav Roy in the final semester, and I had wanted to continue working on it. Krishnamurti's ideas on education — on freedom, attention, and the nature of the self — are not a footnote. They are a living question.

But perhaps that is a story for another blog.

The photo above was shared by all three of us on our Facebook pages back in the day — Flavia, Rupali, and me, outside Pixel Park, bags on our backs, heading into class. Older than most of our professors. Younger than we had ever felt.

Perhaps that is what Back to School really meant — not returning to classrooms, but returning to the child's seat, where learning is renewed by ordinariness, irrelevance, and play.

Skip to content