The Silence Beneath the Noise…
Anyone with tinnitus would have realised this. Social media showed me this poster soon after I got a copy of Murakami's The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle. Facebook and its kind do keep tabs on us! Sometimes the universe, or the algorithm, delivers exactly the message we need at the moment we need it, even if the delivery system is a bit dystopian. I had reached the Zendo after a deep depression brought on by tinnitus, and many things conspired to take care of me. This poster was one of them.
For most people, silence is the absence of sound. For me, silence is the presence of a relentless internal noise. The irony is not lost on me that this condition, a forced constant noise, led me to a Zendo to find actual stillness. Fr. AMA Samy prescribed Zazen and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT). I had to learn to hear a different kind of silence, an inner quietude that exists despite the ringing, not in its absence. I did not know it then, but both practices were teaching me the same thing: how to loosen my grip on the stories my mind was telling.
The Murakami book that came to me with the poster taught me something else too. Japan is a nation that is over-romanticized. Every time there is an international football match involving their national team, the newspapers are full of how the Japanese fans stayed back to clean up the stadium. AMA has often told me about Japanese Zen masters who supported war crimes, the deeply feudal systems, the hereditary inheritance of even spiritual spaces, and the problems of sex and drugs. I got a glimpse of this when I read part of The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle, which exposes the dark side of that society and its psychological underbelly. Its dark detour into the brutal history of Manchuria, through Lieutenant Mamiya's account, shatters any postcard-perfect image of Japan. Murakami uses the surreal to drag the historical and psychological traumas of his nation into the light.
The same is true of Zen. The same society that produced serene rock gardens and haiku also produced a feudal, militaristic system in which Zen masters compromised their ethics to support war crimes, and in which lineage and power often overshadowed true enlightenment. Acknowledging the sex, drugs and feudalism within Zen doesn't destroy the practice. It grounds it in reality and strips away the illusion of purity.
Whether it's the idealized version or the exposed one, treating a nation, a religion or a person as a single character is what goes wrong. It is a form of violence, because it denies the complexity of the human experience. When we pick up one end of the stick, the other end comes with it. There is bad in every good and good in every bad. You cannot have the light without the shadow.
We suffer when we turn anything into a single story, and when we fuse ourselves with that story. (Chimamanda Adichie warned about the danger of a single story, and I have come to see how deep that goes.) Tinnitus became a single story about suffering. Japan becomes a single story about civility or brutality. Zen becomes a single story about enlightenment or hypocrisy. That is the lesson of Zen, ACT and tinnitus too.

One day I found Steven Hayes's book Relational Frame Theory with an inscription on its front page from Dr. Hayes to Fr. AMA. I ran to AMA's room and asked whether he knew Dr. Hayes personally. He said they used to communicate a long time back, and that Dr. Hayes had a lot of questions about Buddhism and Zen. With AMA's permission, I wrote to Dr. Hayes on a Friday. I did not expect any reply. By Sunday there was a long recorded voice message in my inbox. That led me to the ACT immersion and the ACT practitioner course. In the immersion, answering a question, Dr. Hayes spoke about his conversations with AMA on Buddhism and Zen. The academic knowledge came to me only after I had crossed the experiential learning curve.
My closest experience of satori was a moment of defusion. The moment I could step back and see the whole stick. The tinnitus, the depression, the Zendo, the dark side of Japan, the flawed Zen masters, the beauty of the rock gardens and sutras, Bhim the Zendog and Wuji the Zen cat. All of it belonged. None of it had to be rejected. The ringing sound in the ears remained. The world remained. Zendo and Zen too. Nothing was fixed, nothing was removed. Yet the whole stick was there, and there was room enough for all of it.
When you hold the whole stick, you find the space to breathe, to hear the silence beneath the noise, and to find peace in the complexity of human experience.
That is when I heard the silence beneath the noise.



